top of page

NordVPN Dedicated IP Is Good — But Make Sure You’re Solving the Right Problem

Writer: C. Monte Raynor
C. Monte Raynor
Nov 1, 2024
8 min read

Updated: Sep 2

If you’ve followed me for any amount of time, you already know I use VPNs.


A lot.


And yes, I still use NordVPN.


I use it on computers.


I use it on Android TVs.


I’ve used it on Fire Sticks.


And for streaming television content and general commercial VPN use, NordVPN is still one of the services I recommend.


But here’s the thing.


A Dedicated IP VPN and a Personal VPN are not the same thing.


And if you’re a remote worker trying to figure out which one you need, that distinction matters a whole lot more than the word “dedicated” makes it sound.


First, What Is a Dedicated IP?


Normally when you connect to a commercial VPN service, you’re sharing an IP address with other customers connected to that VPN server.


Think about it like an apartment building.


Everybody has a different apartment, but when somebody looks up the address, everybody appears to live at the same building.


That shared IP can create problems.


You may get more CAPTCHAs.


Websites may ask you to verify yourself more often.


Streaming services may recognize that a bunch of people are coming from the same VPN address.


A Dedicated IP changes that.


Instead of sharing that VPN IP address with hundreds or thousands of other users, you get an IP address assigned specifically to you.


That solves a legitimate problem.


But it doesn’t solve every problem.


And that’s where people get confused.


What a Dedicated IP Actually Helps With


For me, a Dedicated IP makes the most sense when you want the flexibility of a commercial VPN but don’t want some of the headaches that come with a shared VPN address.


You may get fewer CAPTCHAs. Some websites may stop treating every login like you just arrived from another planet. You have a consistent IP instead of constantly changing addresses. And for certain services, having that consistency can make your online experience easier.


That’s useful.


I’m not knocking it.


In fact, I bought one. I’ve used one. And I’ve tested one.


But the question you have to ask is: What problem are you actually trying to solve?


If your answer is, “I just want a good commercial VPN for streaming, traveling, or general internet use,” NordVPN may be exactly what you need.


If your answer is, “I’m a remote worker and I need a connection that comes through my normal residential internet connection,” now we’re having a completely different conversation.


A Dedicated IP Is Still a Public VPN


This is probably the most important part of this entire article.


A Dedicated IP gives you an IP address that is dedicated to you.


But that IP address is still coming from the infrastructure of a commercial VPN provider.


That matters. A lot.


When I tested my NordVPN Dedicated IP, I connected through a server in Miami. I had my own unique IP address. Nobody else was sharing it with me.


Sounds good, right?


Then I checked that IP address using services designed to identify VPNs and data-center networks.


And guess what?


They knew. Immediately.


The IP still showed up as coming from a data center. The detection services still recognized that I was connected through a public VPN service.


So yes, a Dedicated IP is a little better than using a regular shared VPN address.


But for a remote worker? Slightly better is not the same thing as the right tool.


Why I Do Not Recommend NordVPN for Remote Work Location Privacy


Let me be very clear here.


I use NordVPN.


I recommend NordVPN for certain things.


I am also a NordVPN affiliate.


But I would not tell one of my remote-work clients that a NordVPN Dedicated IP is the best solution for maintaining their normal home-network presence while traveling.


It isn’t.


The basic architecture hasn’t changed. A commercial VPN server lives in a data center. Your traffic comes out of that data center. Giving you one dedicated address inside that infrastructure does not magically turn it into residential internet.


The IP is dedicated. The network it comes from is still commercial VPN infrastructure.


So What Is the Better Option for a Remote Worker?


For the people I help through Work With No Borders, I prefer a Personal VPN system.


The difference is ownership and location.


With a Personal VPN, you control the client, the server and the encrypted connection between them.


The server sits at a residential internet connection you control or trust. That might be your house. It might be a family member’s house. It might be another location you have permission to use.


When you connect back through that system, your internet traffic comes out through that residential connection.


That is fundamentally different from connecting to a commercial VPN server sitting in a data center.


And that difference is why I separate these two products so clearly.


Dedicated IP vs. Personal VPN


Here’s the easiest way I know to explain it.


A NordVPN Dedicated IP gives you one consistent IP address, commercial VPN infrastructure, lots of flexibility, easier setup, multiple supported devices, and usefulness for general privacy and streaming.


A Personal VPN gives you a residential internet connection, equipment you control, a server location you choose, more control over the entire system, and no shared commercial VPN server.


They are both VPNs. They are not solving the same problem.


Where I Still Use NordVPN


This is where NordVPN still fits very well for me.


Streaming.


That is probably my biggest use case.


I have used NordVPN on Android TVs, computers, Fire Sticks, and other devices where I want to connect through a commercial VPN server and access content from another location.


For that? NordVPN is easy.


I can open the app, pick a server and go.


No routers. No server sitting at somebody’s house. No network engineering project.


Sometimes you just want to watch TV.


And I don’t need to break out WireGuard and two routers because I want to watch a football game.


Come on now.


One Fire TV Warning


There is one thing you need to pay attention to if you’re buying Amazon streaming devices.


Amazon has been changing the operating system used on some newer Fire TV devices.


That means NordVPN support can vary depending on the exact Fire TV or Fire Stick you own.


Older Fire Sticks and supported Fire TV devices may work perfectly fine. Newer hardware may not support the same VPN apps or features the way older devices did.


So before you buy a device specifically because you plan to run NordVPN on it: Check compatibility first.


Don’t assume that because your five-year-old Fire Stick worked, the one you buy tomorrow will work exactly the same way.


Ask me how many times technology has taught me that lesson.


What About Banking?


You could use a commercial VPN like NordVPN for banking.


I don’t.


These days, if I’m away from home and need to access banking or something else sensitive, I use my Personal VPN.


Why?


Because I would rather come through a residential internet connection that I control than through a commercial VPN data center.


That doesn’t mean NordVPN can’t work for banking. It can. It just isn’t what I personally use anymore.


And that distinction matters because this article is supposed to reflect how I actually use these tools today—not just what they are technically capable of doing.


What About Streaming Services Blocking VPNs?


This is one reason Dedicated IP addresses became popular in the first place.


Shared VPN IP addresses can attract attention because lots of customers are using the same address.


A Dedicated IP reduces that shared-IP problem because the address belongs only to you.


That can help.


But I would never promise that a streaming service will never recognize or block a VPN connection.


These companies change their detection systems constantly. VPN providers change things. Streaming companies change things. Amazon changes things. Netflix changes things. Five minutes later everybody changes it again.


Welcome to technology.


So I look at a Dedicated IP as another tool—not a magic invisibility button.


One Thing I Like About NordVPN: Flexibility


This is still one of the biggest reasons I keep it around.


NordVPN gives you a lot of options.


If I need a server in one location, I can select it. If that one isn’t working well, I can try another. If I’m traveling, I don’t have to think very hard about it.


Open the app. Connect. Done.


That convenience has value.


A Personal VPN is almost the opposite. You get more control, but with that control comes more responsibility.


You need equipment. You need a server location. You need adequate internet speeds. You need to configure it properly. And you need to think about what happens if the server location loses power or internet.


There is no free lunch.


I Actually Tested This on a GL.iNet Router


One thing I did that I think is important is I didn’t just read the NordVPN marketing page.


I set the thing up.


I downloaded the NordVPN configuration for my Dedicated IP and loaded it into a GL.iNet travel router.


Then I tested it.


I looked at the IP address. I tested detection. I ran speed tests.


Then I switched the same router over to my Personal VPN connection running back to a residential location.


The difference was obvious.


The NordVPN connection worked. The Dedicated IP worked. But the connection could still be identified as a commercial VPN/data-center connection.


My Personal VPN connection came out through the residential internet service at the server location.


That test is really what changed the way I explain Dedicated IPs to people.


Because the question isn’t: Does the VPN work?


Of course it works.


The question is: Does it solve your particular problem?


Those are two completely different questions.


So Should You Buy NordVPN Dedicated IP?


Maybe.


I know that’s not the internet answer you wanted.


You wanted: YES! THIS IS THE BEST VPN EVER!


Sorry.


It depends.


If you want a consistent commercial VPN IP, potentially fewer CAPTCHAs, a stable address for general internet use, streaming flexibility, and a commercial VPN that works across lots of devices, then a NordVPN Dedicated IP may make a lot of sense.


I use NordVPN myself, and I continue to recommend it for those types of use cases.


But if you are a remote worker and your primary requirement is maintaining a connection through a residential home network while traveling, I would not buy a Dedicated IP and assume the problem is solved.


For that use case, I recommend a Personal VPN system.


The Bottom Line


A Dedicated IP is better than a shared VPN IP for certain things.


But the word dedicated can make it sound more private than it really is.


You have your own IP. You do not have your own VPN provider infrastructure. There is a difference.


For streaming, travel and everyday commercial VPN use? I still use NordVPN.


For remote workers who need a residential Personal VPN architecture? Different tool. Different problem. Different answer.


If NordVPN fits what you’re trying to do, you can use my NordVPN affiliate link to check out the current plans and Dedicated IP options. It helps support the channel and does not change what you pay.



And if you’re trying to figure out whether you need a public VPN, Dedicated IP or Personal VPN for your particular setup, don’t guess.


That is exactly the kind of thing I help people work through with Work With No Borders.


Because when your job depends on the network working the way you expect it to, “I thought this was the same thing” is not where you want to end up.



Until next time,


MexitPlans Monte


“I’m Out.”

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page